Conscious Sedation in Dental Practices: Meeting CQC and IACSD Standards
Conscious sedation dental CQC inspections test one thing above all: whether your sedation service meets the national IACSD standards, and whether you can prove it. Sedation helps anxious patients, people with additional needs and those having complex treatment, but it carries real risk. When I inspected practices offering sedation as a CQC inspector, the gaps I found were rarely about clinical skill. They were about evidence, governance and team training.
What CQC says about conscious sedation
CQC's Dental mythbuster 10: Safe and effective conscious sedation explains that inspectors consider sedation under the safe key question. It links sedation to four regulations:
Regulation 12: Safe care and treatment
Regulation 11: Need for consent
Regulation 18: Staffing
Regulation 15: Premises and equipment
The mythbuster is direct: to demonstrate safe and effective care, providers must follow the Intercollegiate Advisory Committee for Sedation in Dentistry (IACSD) standards, published in 2015 and updated in March 2020. Practitioners should also be aware of the SDCEP Conscious Sedation in Dentistry guidance.
The IACSD 2020 standards in brief
The Standards for Conscious Sedation in the Provision of Dental Care create a national standard that applies to everyone who practises sedation, whether dentist, doctor, nurse or dental care professional. The full 2020 report is long, but the requirements CQC focuses on fall into a handful of areas.
Training and continuing competence
All members of the team must have undertaken validated education and training and demonstrated competence. Courses that are purely didactic, without supervised clinical practice, assessment and external quality assurance, are not enough for unsupervised practice.
The report sets recommended minimum numbers of supervised cases, for example 10 for inhalation sedation and 20 for intravenous midazolam. To maintain competence, every team member must complete at least 12 hours of relevant CPD every 5 years. Clinicians who rarely use a technique must consider mentoring, retraining or stopping.
For dental nurses, the recognised pathway is the Certificate in Dental Sedation Nursing or an equivalent accredited qualification. All team members need Immediate Life Support, and Paediatric Immediate Life Support where children are treated.
The team
For standard techniques such as inhalation sedation and intravenous midazolam in adults, an operator-sedationist may work with a second appropriately trained person, usually a sedation-trained dental nurse. More advanced techniques, such as propofol infusions, require a dedicated sedationist who is not also carrying out the treatment. For children under 12, only nitrous oxide and oxygen is considered a basic technique.
Assessment, information and consent
Every patient needs a documented pre-operative assessment and a justified choice of technique. Written information must be given in advance, including a separate sheet for the escort. The report says consent obtained on the day of treatment is not appropriate except where immediate treatment is in the patient's best interests, and consent obtained earlier must be reconfirmed on the day. Sedated patients cannot give valid consent.
Monitoring, recovery and discharge
For inhalation sedation, clinical monitoring will usually suffice. For all other techniques, the minimum is pulse oximetry and non-invasive blood pressure, with a written contemporaneous record. Competence in cannulation is mandatory for all techniques other than inhalation sedation.
An escort is required for all techniques except inhalation sedation in adults, and children under 16 need an escort even for inhalation sedation. If an escort cannot be assured, treatment under sedation must not go ahead. Patients must be formally assessed against discharge criteria and given written aftercare instructions and out-of-hours contact details.
Environment and equipment
Equipment must be available, working and maintained to the manufacturer's schedule, with maintenance records kept for inspection. The setting must allow access for emergency services and transfer of the patient. Your emergency drugs and equipment should reflect the techniques you use, which I cover in my guide to emergency medicines in dental practices.
Audit and incident reporting
IACSD describes robust, regular audit involving the whole team as a core requirement. You must keep a clinical log of the number and types of sedation cases and any complications, and investigate all adverse events.
What a conscious sedation dental CQC inspection covers
Dental mythbuster 10 lists what inspectors explore. From my own inspections, these are the questions to be ready for:
Can you show accredited training and clinical supervision for each sedationist who started after the IACSD standards were introduced?
Is there a clinical logbook and evidence of maintained competence and CPD?
Are ILS and, where relevant, PILS certificates current for the whole team?
How do you review critical incidents relating to sedation?
What sedation audits have you completed, and what changed as a result?
How are patients assessed and prepared, and is consent valid?
Are monitoring records complete for every case?
Are recovery, discharge and aftercare arrangements documented?
Is the sedation equipment serviced according to the manufacturer's instructions?
Visiting sedationists
Many practices use a visiting sedationist. That does not transfer responsibility. CQC expects you to have systems to check that they are suitably qualified and competent, that their equipment and medicines are fit for purpose, and that they comply with the sedation standards. Hold copies of their training, GDC or GMC registration, indemnity, life support certificates and audit, and agree in writing who supplies and maintains what.
Regulation 19 recruitment checks apply to visiting clinicians too, as I explain in my guide to safer recruitment in dental practices, and sedation training should be part of your mandatory training records. The governance arrangements should sit within your practice governance policy.
How I can help
If you are adding sedation to an existing practice, or registering a new practice that will offer it, I can review your sedation policy, audits, team training records and patient documentation against the IACSD standards and CQC's expectations. Find out more about my CQC registration application support.
If you want an independent check of your practice, a dental CQC mock inspection can help you spot gaps before CQC does.
Sources
Want to talk it through? Book a free 15-minute call
Comments