CQC fit and proper person test: checks and qualifications

Updated: 5 days ago
A senior job title isn’t the only thing that can bring someone within scope. In England, Regulation 5 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 sets out the CQC fit and proper person test for directors of registered providers, and for anyone performing the functions of, or functions equivalent or similar to those of, a director.
It’s understandable to focus on whether a person has the right qualifications, but fitness involves more than credentials. Providers must also consider good character, competence, skills, experience and health, whether the person has been involved in serious misconduct or mismanagement, and the grounds set out in Schedule 4.
Drawing on my 12 years as a CQC inspector, I explain who must meet the requirement, including interim appointments, how criminal record and professional register checks fit into an assessment, which qualifications matter, and how Schedule 4 can affect a decision. I also explain how the CQC requirement differs from NHS England’s Fit and Proper Person Test Framework, which applies to NHS bodies rather than independent providers.
Table of Contents
Criminal conviction and professional register checks
In England, Regulation 19 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 sets requirements for people employed to carry on a regulated activity. According to Regulation 1 of the 2014 Regulations, most of the Regulations, including Regulation 19, came into force on 1 April 2015. For directors, Regulation 5 applies instead: Regulation 19(6) says its main fitness and information requirements do not apply where Regulation 5 applies.
Under Regulation 5, the information specified in Schedule 3 must be available to supply to CQC for each director, just as it must be for staff under Regulation 19. Schedule 3 includes proof of identity with a recent photograph, a criminal record certificate where the role is eligible, satisfactory evidence of conduct in previous health or social care employment, evidence of relevant qualifications, a full employment history with a written explanation of any gaps, and relevant health information.
Employment history and references can help providers assess a candidate’s suitability. Review the recorded history, follow up gaps or inconsistencies, and consider references alongside other recruitment information. For example, explore and record any difference between an application and a reference. This makes the decision traceable rather than relying on an unexamined document.
DBS eligibility needs careful, case-by-case consideration. CQC expects providers to carry out a DBS check on a director where the position and role meet the eligibility criteria, and those criteria determine whether a standard or enhanced check applies. Where a director meets the criteria, providers should also establish whether the person is on the children’s or adults’ barred list. Where a director is not eligible, providers must still carry out the other checks Regulation 5 requires, such as confirming the person is not an undischarged bankrupt or prohibited from holding the office.
A criminal conviction, or erasure or removal from a professional register, must be considered when assessing a director’s character under Part 2 of Schedule 4, but neither automatically prevents appointment. If you decide a person is suitable despite such information, record your reasons, as CQC guidance expects. Where a role requires registration with a professional regulator, CQC guidance says providers should only appoint candidates who meet that requirement.
Keep director fitness evidence confidential but accessible, because Regulation 5 requires the Schedule 3 information to be available to supply to CQC. Record the checks, the evidence considered and the reasons for each decision, then document how the information informed the appointment. Providers seeking to strengthen their wider recruitment documentation and personnel compliance can also turn to Altum HR for specialist workplace and employment advice.
Good character and professional qualifications
Regulation 5 requires a director to be of good character and have the qualifications, competence, skills and experience needed for the role. The person must also be able, by reason of their health and after reasonable adjustments, to properly perform the tasks intrinsic to the role. These requirements apply to directors, and people in equivalent roles, of registered health and social care providers in England that are not individuals or partnerships.
Assess good character using all the available evidence, not a single document or reference. CQC expects the process to take account of a person’s honesty, trustworthiness, reliability and respectfulness, and providers must have regard to the matters in Part 2 of Schedule 4. Separately, Regulation 5 says a director must not have been responsible for, privy to, contributed to or facilitated any serious misconduct or mismanagement in carrying on a regulated activity. CQC guidance sets no time limit for considering serious misconduct or responsibility for failure in a previous role.
Consider qualifications in context. A certificate alone does not demonstrate that someone has the competence or experience required for a particular director role. Assess whether the candidate’s training and practical experience match the responsibilities they will hold. Also weigh evidence of judgement, leadership skills and understanding of the care service.
Under Regulation 5, whether a director is fit and proper depends on a combined assessment of good character, qualifications, competence, skills, experience and health, together with the serious misconduct test and the unfitness grounds in Part 1 of Schedule 4. Health is considered after reasonable adjustments, in line with the Equality Act 2010, and a long-term condition or disability does not in itself prevent appointment.
For a clear decision, record the evidence considered and explain how it relates to the role. CQC expects providers to follow guidelines on value-based recruitment, appraisal, development and disciplinary action for directors, including the seven principles of public life, known as the Nolan principles. In NHS bodies, NHS England’s Fit and Proper Person Test Framework adds further steps, such as an annual self-attestation by each board member and an annual submission by the chair to the NHS England regional director. That framework applies to NHS bodies such as NHS trusts, foundation trusts and integrated care boards, not to independent providers.
A structured independent review by a former CQC inspector can help identify gaps in how evidence supports director fitness decisions.
Schedule 4 grounds for being an unfit person
Schedule 4 of the 2014 Regulations has two parts. Part 1 sets out the unfit person test: if any of its grounds applies, the person must not be appointed or kept in place as a director. Part 2 lists matters that providers must consider when assessing good character. The distinction matters: a matter that requires consideration is not automatically a bar to appointment.
Part 1 of Schedule 4 covers being an undischarged bankrupt or subject to sequestration, a bankruptcy restrictions order, a debt relief order moratorium, or an undischarged arrangement with creditors. It also covers inclusion on the children’s or adults’ barred list and being prohibited from holding the office by law, for example under the Companies Act or Charities Act. Criminal convictions are not a Part 1 ground. Providers should establish whether any listed circumstance applies; if one does, the person is unfit.
Part 2 of Schedule 4 lists two matters to consider when assessing character: whether the person has been convicted of an offence in the UK, or of an offence elsewhere that would be an offence in the UK, and whether they have been erased, removed or struck off a register of health or social work professionals. Serious misconduct and mismanagement are dealt with separately under Regulation 5(3)(d). CQC guidance gives the example of a director implicated in a health and safety breach: the provider must establish the director’s role and, if the breach is attributable to their conduct, CQC would expect the provider to find them unfit.
Examine past events carefully. For example, when considering a director’s record, establish what happened, the person’s role and whether the conduct raises a current concern about fitness. CQC guidance says there is no time limit for considering serious misconduct or responsibility for failure in a previous role. An incident’s age alone does not remove it from consideration.
For a defensible decision, providers should distinguish between a Part 1 ground, which makes a person unfit, and evidence informing a broader character assessment. Record the relevant facts, how they relate to the director’s conduct, and the reasoning behind the outcome. This makes clear whether the decision followed a specific ground or a balanced assessment of character, skills and responsibility under Regulation 5.

Who must meet the fit and proper person test
In England, Regulation 5 applies to registered providers that are not individuals or partnerships. It covers directors and anyone performing the functions of, or functions equivalent or similar to those of, a director. CQC guidance says that for NHS bodies this includes executive and non-executive, permanent, interim and associate positions, irrespective of voting rights. It also applies to equivalent posts in other providers, including trustees of charitable bodies and members of the governing bodies of unincorporated associations.
A temporary or interim title does not remove the requirement, so judge scope by the role a person performs rather than their job title. Where a local authority is the provider, CQC guidance says the regulation does not apply to elected members, because they are accountable through a different route.
The CQC requirement under Regulation 5 applies to registered providers across health and social care, including NHS bodies. NHS trusts, foundation trusts and integrated care boards must also follow NHS England’s Fit and Proper Person Test Framework for board members, which builds on the CQC requirement. Independent providers are assessed against Regulation 5 and CQC’s guidance; the NHS England framework does not apply to them, although NHS England says organisations outside its scope may follow it as good practice.
Review current directors’ fitness regularly. CQC guidance says providers must decide how often to review fitness based on the assessed risk posed by the individual or role, and must respond promptly to concerns that arise after appointment. NHS bodies following the NHS England framework review fitness annually. This keeps checks connected to the person’s current conduct and responsibilities, rather than treating appointment as the end of the process. For operators undergoing corporate restructuring or ownership changes, maintaining robust leadership records is also essential during due diligence, with platforms such as healthcarebizbrokers.com assisting owners through healthcare business sales and valuations.
If a director no longer meets the requirements, the provider must take necessary and proportionate action to ensure the role is held by someone who does. If the director is a health care professional, social worker or other professional registered with a health or social care regulator, the provider must also inform that regulator. As a former CQC inspector, I use mock inspections to help providers check whether their governance processes clearly identify the roles and decisions requiring scrutiny.
CQC Consultancy
I help providers understand CQC requirements and strengthen their compliance approach. I started my career in frontline clinical care and then spent 12 years as a CQC inspector. If you are unsure whether roles are in scope or how to organise evidence for director assessments, my CQC compliance guidance can clarify the process and identify areas needing attention.
For a broader view of how governance and compliance arrangements work in practice, my CQC mock inspections assess readiness and highlight gaps before a formal assessment. If you are preparing to register, my CQC registration support explains the steps involved.
Choose support that fits your current need, whether you’re reviewing existing arrangements or preparing a new service. For a conversation about your requirements, contact me.
Make fitness assessments part of good governance
Use the CQC fit and proper person test to build a dependable approach to leadership oversight. Clarify who owns assessment decisions, where supporting evidence is held and how emerging concerns reach the right decision-makers. A defined process helps an organisation respond consistently as roles and circumstances change.
Consider whether your governance arrangements make these responsibilities easy to follow. Clear records should show how decisions were reached, while regular discussion can help leaders spot gaps before they affect oversight. The aim is not paperwork for its own sake, but a sound basis for responsible, informed decisions about leadership.
If you would value guidance on strengthening your approach, get in touch with me. Taking a considered next step can help you move forward with greater clarity and confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Fit and proper person requirement: what does it mean for your organisation?
The requirement means your organisation needs a sound way to decide who can hold senior responsibility for care. The board should understand which roles are in scope, who oversees assessments and how concerns are escalated. For example, a change in a director’s responsibilities may affect which evidence is relevant. Clear accountability helps the organisation make consistent decisions and show how it manages leadership suitability.
How will it be enforced?
CQC checks that a provider has a proper process for assessing directors, both at registration and when information of concern arises, and leadership forms part of its assessment of whether a service is well-led. It may examine director personnel files and appraisal records. CQC cannot prosecute for a breach of Regulation 5, but it can take regulatory action, such as imposing conditions on a provider’s registration where appropriate.
What is the requirement?
The requirement makes a registered provider responsible for ensuring directors are fit and proper for their roles. It is not simply a recruitment formality or a check completed once at appointment. The organisation needs a robust process for making and recording decisions, and should respond if information later raises concerns about a director’s continuing suitability.
What practical steps should organisations take now?
Map senior roles against actual decision-making responsibilities, assign accountability for assessments and set a regular review process. Keep the process clear for new appointments and emerging concerns. I offer a free 15-minute discovery call to discuss what support may fit, and I support providers in Liverpool, Manchester, London, Chester, Leeds, Sheffield, Birmingham, Portsmouth, Cornwall, Devon, Lancaster, Carlisle and elsewhere in England. My consultancy support does not guarantee registration or replace legal, clinical, data protection, information security or other specialist professional advice.
What is the CQC fit and proper person test?
It is the requirement under Regulation 5 for registered providers to make sure their directors are fit and proper for their roles. The assessment considers whether a person has the character, qualifications, competence, skills, experience and health for their responsibilities, and whether any grounds make them unfit. It applies to the role a person performs, not just their job title, so equivalent senior decision-makers may also fall within scope.
Which CQC-registered providers must apply the fit and proper person test?
It applies to registered providers that are not individuals or partnerships, such as companies, NHS bodies and charities. It covers directors and people in equivalent roles, including trustees of charitable bodies. Where a local authority is the provider, CQC guidance says it does not apply to elected members.



Comments