
Duty of Candour in Dental Practices: A Practical Guide to Regulation 20

Duty of candour in dental practices is a legal requirement, not just good manners, and it applies to every CQC-registered provider. When I was a CQC inspector, I found that most dental teams were honest with patients by instinct. What they often lacked was a clear process: who decides whether an incident is notifiable, who speaks to the patient, what goes in the letter and where the record is kept. This guide explains what Regulation 20 requires and how to show CQC you are meeting it.

The statutory duty and the professional duty
There are two duties of candour, and dental teams sometimes confuse them.
The professional duty applies to each registered dental professional. The GDC describes it in its guidance on the professional duty of candour as being open and honest with patients when something goes wrong.
The statutory duty applies to your organisation as the registered provider. It is set out in Regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 and enforced by CQC. CQC's Regulation 20 guidance makes the point that a clinician meeting their professional duty is not enough on its own. If a notifiable safety incident happens, the provider must also carry out the specific statutory steps.
What counts as a notifiable safety incident?
CQC's page on notifiable safety incidents sets out three tests. An incident is notifiable when all of these apply:
It was unintended or unexpected.
It occurred while you were providing a regulated activity.
In the reasonable opinion of a healthcare professional, it has caused, or might lead to, one of the harm thresholds in the regulation.
For dental practices, which are not NHS bodies, Regulation 20(9) applies. The incident must appear to have resulted in, or need treatment to prevent:
The death of the person, directly due to the incident rather than their illness or underlying condition.
A sensory, motor or intellectual impairment lasting, or likely to last, at least 28 continuous days.
Changes to the structure of the person's body.
Prolonged pain or prolonged psychological harm, meaning at least 28 continuous days.
The shortening of the person's life expectancy.
Three points surprise many teams. First, fault does not matter. CQC is clear that an incident can be notifiable even where nobody did anything wrong. Second, the patient having consented to the procedure does not stop an incident being notifiable. Third, near misses are not notifiable safety incidents, although you should still learn from them.
A dental example from CQC
CQC publishes examples of notifiable safety incidents, and one is set in a dental practice. A child with an unknown latex allergy attended a check-up, the dentist wore latex gloves and the child had a severe anaphylactic reaction needing hospital treatment. The child recovered fully. Nobody knew about the allergy and there was no fault, but CQC says it qualifies as a notifiable safety incident because treatment was needed to prevent death.
Other situations I would want a team to think through include an extraction of the wrong tooth, a nerve injury after an implant or extraction that does not resolve within 28 days, or an instrument fragment left in a patient. Whether each one is notifiable depends on the facts and the harm, so the decision and the reasons behind it should be recorded.
What you must do, step by step
CQC's guidance on what you must do sets out the statutory steps. As soon as reasonably practicable after you become aware of a notifiable safety incident, you must:
Tell the person (or someone lawfully acting for them), face to face, that the incident has happened.
Apologise.
Give a true account of what happened, as far as you know it at that point.
Explain what further enquiries you will make.
Follow up the conversation in writing, including the apology and the results of any enquiries.
Keep a secure written record of all meetings and communications.
You must also offer reasonable support, such as an interpreter or details of advocacy and support services. If the person cannot be contacted or does not want to talk, record your attempts.
Saying sorry is not admitting liability
The fear I heard most often from dentists was that an apology would be used against them. CQC's guidance quotes NHS Resolution's "Saying Sorry" leaflet, which makes clear that an apology is not an admission of liability. The GDC says the same in its candour guidance. A sincere, early apology is also, in my experience, one of the best ways to stop a concern turning into a formal complaint. If it does become a complaint, my post on complaints handling in private dentistry explains what CQC expects.
What I looked for as an inspector
CQC explains how it regulates Regulation 20. It is one of the fundamental standards, and inspectors talk to staff and the registered manager to check they understand it. On inspection I would typically:
Ask the registered manager to explain the duty of candour and give an example of when it would apply.
Ask nurses and receptionists what they would do if something went wrong with a patient's treatment.
Look at the incident log and pick out anything that might have met the harm threshold.
Check whether a candour decision was recorded and, where needed, whether the letter and records exist.
Check whether lessons were shared with the team.
CQC says Regulation 20 allows it to move directly to criminal enforcement action. Its other options include warning notices, requirement notices and conditions on registration. In practice the commonest finding is weaker: a team that cannot explain the duty, or an incident log with no candour decision. That still affects your well-led rating.
Building a simple candour process
You do not need a complicated system. A practice of any size can put these in place:
A short duty of candour policy that names who decides whether an incident is notifiable.
An incident form with a tick box: "Does this meet the duty of candour threshold? Yes or no, and why."
A template letter covering the apology, the account, further enquiries and a contact name.
A secure place for candour records, separate from the clinical notes but cross-referenced.
Training at induction, with a scenario discussed at a team meeting each year.
Some incidents also need a statutory notification to CQC. My CQC statutory notifications checklist explains which ones.
If you are registering a new practice, CQC expects you to show you understand the duty of candour at registration, and your policies should reflect it. My registration application support covers this. You will also find policy templates on my free CQC resources page.
Final thoughts
The duty of candour in dental practices comes down to being open, being quick and writing it down. Most teams already do the first. Put a clear process around it and you protect your patients, your clinicians and your rating.



Comments